I bought a DVD copy of this years ago, because I’d only ever seen clips of it. AND YET, I only watched it for the first time today.
First of all, I never knew that Cinderella was written for television first THEN put on the stage. According to the internet, it was a live color production created for CBS staring Julie Andrews. Sadly, the color version no longer exists. I guess I should be happy even this crap copy exists.
The movie opens with “The Prince is Giving a Ball” where various women say they are going to the ball or wish they were going to the ball . . . Is that a woman in a negligee? Okay, 1950s. Pushing the envelope. Respect. This is followed by Cinderella (Andrews) being treated poorly by her Step-Mother (Illka Chase) and imagining her life being an adventure. The part that came after this which made me happy was the King and Queen (Howard Lindsay and Dorothy Stickney respectively) discussing their son. The Queen starts singing their son’s many titles and the King declare, “Masie! I know his name!” Dorothy Stickney has a small part in one of my favorite movies of all time “The Uninvited”. As the King and Queen argue about the cost of the ball, the Prince enters (played by Jon Cypher who I know as Man-at-Arms from the original Masters of the Universe film). His father makes him re-assure his mother that he’s excited to be pawed by every girl in the kingdom while wearing uncomfortable clothes.
This original version really spend little time with Cinderella at the beginning. It’s not until the Fairy Godmother (Edie Adams from The Apartment) shows up that Cinderella shows some personality. I was surprised the Cinderella knows her godmother and just didn’t know she was magic. Why isn’t she living with this woman if she’s an established godmother? I would be so mad if I had a godmother who left me with an evil stepmother. AND it turned out that she had powers the whole time? Although I like that the Fairy Godmother is young, I really feel like her whole “You need to help yourself” shtick is just an excuse not to have to adopt Cinderella. Of course, the song “Impossible” makes more sense when the Fairy Godmother is pretending NOT to be a fairy. When she does finally break out her wand, Cinderella sees she’s changed into a fancy dress and cloak. The Godmother blows dust off the shoulder and states, “This old thing? I’ve have it for 832 years.”
All of the transformations happen quickly with camera tricks. Cinderella’s dress is rather modern with an empire waist and train. However, the Prince is bland. I confess to hoping he’d have more going on when they first introduced the character. But . . . nope. He’s all about Cinderella’s look and doesn’t have much to say to her besides, “I want you to call me Christopher”. They just dance . . . a lot. There is a semi-philosophical conversation before the song “Do I Love You Because You’re Beautiful?”, but Cinderella kind of spoils it because she says that girls don’t care about the why when they fall in love. That’s how you end up with a partner riddled with red flags. Bad, Cinderella. Go back to your corner!
The best part of the movie was the two step-sisters played by character actors Alice Ghostly and Kaye Ballard. I know these are the two best characters in any version of Rodgers and Hammerstein’s Cinderella, but considering that they were the first, it’s clear how later versions mimicked them. This might be why they get more dialogue in the 1960s and 1990s Cinderellas. At least this pair managed to say some hilarious lines that I’m fairly certain were improved. No shade to Dame Julie Andrews, of course. She gets to make some great surprised faces when the step-family sings “A Lovely Night”.

Quisque iaculis facilisis lacinia. Mauris euismod pellentesque tellus sit amet mollis.